01 · Entertainment value
×1
Measuring appeal and likeability.
Survey questions
- How much did you like or dislike this scene?
Faith, storytelling, and its influence on modern American audiences.
A groundbreaking new study explores how today’s TV and film audiences respond to faith on screen.
A roadmap for filmmakers
How can creators tell authentic stories with faith in a way that tangibly builds engagement?
Why do some stories land better than others?
The index brings audience responses, social listening, and research-informed AI coding together to examine what happens when faith becomes part of the story.
Age distribution of survey respondents · HarrisX
The foundation
Published 2026
Fieldwork: September 9–18 and November 13–25, 2025.
Professionally recruited consumers who watch TV or movies at least weekly completed an online survey. Jewish and Muslim respondents were oversampled to achieve readable samples among major U.S. faith groups. Religious affiliation was weighted to reflect the U.S. population.
56% watch TV or movies daily. 78% identify as spiritual, religious, or a person of faith.
| Age | Share |
|---|---|
| 18–34 | 26% |
| 35–49 | 24% |
| 50–64 | 25% |
| 65+ | 25% |
| Gender | Share |
|---|---|
| Male | 50% |
| Female | 50% |
| Identity | Share |
|---|---|
| Spiritual | 35% |
| Religious | 38% |
| Person of faith | 40% |
| None of the above | 22% |
| Identity | Respondents |
|---|---|
| Christian | 5,579 |
| Catholic | 2,072 |
| Protestant | 2,266 |
| Jewish | 2,467 |
| Muslim | 2,652 |
| Eastern religions | 90 |
| Other religion | 265 |
| Atheist / agnostic | 1,538 |
Religiosity is a multiple-response measure. Catholic and Protestant are included within Christian identity, so these rows should not be added as separate groups.
The report describes 32 avid entertainment consumers in its qualitative phase, recruited for a diverse mix of demographics and ideologies. The quantitative phase tested 106 scenes from 50 series and films.
Organic YouTube comments were grouped into themes. A research-informed AI taxonomy of more than 130 tones was then used to code the scenes consistently.
Read methodology and coding details in the reportA first-of-its-kind evaluation system
Each scene is evaluated against three core pillars. The weights reflect their relative contribution to the index.
×1
Measuring appeal and likeability.
×1.5
Authenticity, accuracy, and storytelling features.
×2
Sentiment and interest in future content.
The study calls these features “totems.”
The highlights
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
The top 10
Explore the scenes audiences found most impactful. Open a profile for audience scores, storytelling features, and viewer responses.
Ranked by the all-consumer index. Scores are weighted index values, not percentages.
The PittDr. Robby Thanks WhitakerJudaism80.6Index score"7:00 PM," The Pitt, S1, E13 (2025), HBO Max, et. Al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Shows characters exploring their faith | 77% |
| Weaves faith naturally into the story or character journey | 75% |
| Places faith in contemporary/modern settings | 75% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 86% |
| Faith portrayal | 77% |
| Engagement impact | 75% |
"It shows that in the darkest times of life, people can look to God for courage and strength."
“It shows characters genuinely grappling with their beliefs in a meaningful way.”
Young SheldonSheldon Convincing Mom to Believe in GodChristianity78.2Index score"A Crisis of Faith and Octopus Aliens," Young Sheldon, S2, E3 (2017), CBS, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 76% |
| Is emotionally moving | 74% |
| Shows realistic characters and situations | 73% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 85% |
| Faith portrayal | 77% |
| Engagement impact | 71% |
“It shows how people have questions about their faith but continue to try to understand it.”
“The character belief were expressed genuinely and with emotional depth, making their faith seem authentic.”
Nobody Wants ThisI Love YouJudaism77.8Index score"Bat Mitzvah Crashers," Nobody Wants This, S1, E10 (2024), Netflix, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
The source webpage lists Muslim rank #87; the downloadable report (p. 42) lists #43. This profile follows the report.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 80% |
| Shows realistic characters and situations | 78% |
| Shows characters exploring their faith | 77% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 88% |
| Faith portrayal | 78% |
| Engagement impact | 68% |
“The characters show sincerity and depth in their beliefs. That emotional honesty is what made it stand out as a good portrayal.”
“Rather than being a theatrical display, their generosity and humility were a reflection of genuine religion.”
Hacksaw RidgePlead GuiltyChristianity77.4Index scoreHacksaw Ridge (2016), Lionsgate, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Weaves faith naturally into the story or character journey | 73% |
| Shows characters exploring their faith | 73% |
| Is emotionally moving | 73% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 82% |
| Faith portrayal | 74% |
| Engagement impact | 72% |
“Because the character is trusting in something unseen despite the odds which reflects true faith.”
“He was willing to stand by the guidelines of his faith and not use a gun to kill.”
Hacksaw RidgeDesmond Asks God for StrengthChristianity77.3Index scoreHacksaw Ridge (2016), Lionsgate, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 73% |
| Has characters who feel layered and complex | 73% |
| Is emotionally moving | 72% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 83% |
| Faith portrayal | 73% |
| Engagement impact | 72% |
“It shows faith in a light of following through even in the toughest circumstances when we don't think we can but yet with faith we can.”
“It shows genuine belief, struggles, and hope, feeling realistic and relatable.”
Nobody Wants ThisNoah's SermonJudaism77Index scoreThe source embeds a Hacksaw Ridge clip here. The scene reference is “Pilot,” Nobody Wants This, S1 E1, 22:20–23:45 on Netflix.
"Pilot," Nobody Wants This, S1, E1 (2024), Netflix, et. al.; Time stamp for the clip on Netflix is (22:20-23:45)
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 78% |
| Places faith in contemporary/modern settings | 75% |
| Shows characters exploring their faith | 72% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 87% |
| Faith portrayal | 74% |
| Engagement impact | 70% |
“[The scene] indicated that all you have to do is look around and God is there with you.”
“The way the Rabbi brings everyday occurrences to religion. It’s a good way to bring faith in a relatable manner.”
The West WingParable ConversationChristianity76.2Index score"Take This Sabbath Day," The West Wing, S1, E14 (2000), National Broadcasting Company (NBC), et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 79% |
| Shows characters exploring their faith | 70% |
| Shows realistic characters and situations | 70% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 82% |
| Faith portrayal | 73% |
| Engagement impact | 70% |
“…It shows that faith can coexist with uncertainty, which makes it more relatable and real.”
“Because that scene was about God helps those who help themselves, and not that you’re waiting on a miracle from God.”
Hacksaw RidgeDesmond is Jailed & Speaks in CourtChristianity75.9Index scoreHacksaw Ridge (2016), Lionsgate, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 76% |
| Shows realistic characters and situations | 74% |
| Is emotionally moving | 69% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 86% |
| Faith portrayal | 70% |
| Engagement impact | 71% |
“The guy was sticking to his beliefs and his morals with no compromise.”
“…it captured the depth, complexity, and emotional truth of what it means to believe.”
SelmaMLK Jr. in JailChristianity73.6Index scoreSelma (2015), Paramount Pictures, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 74% |
| Shows realistic characters and situations | 74% |
| Has characters who feel layered and complex | 73% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 80% |
| Faith portrayal | 72% |
| Engagement impact | 66% |
“It showed unwavering belief despite doubt, struggle, and uncertain outcomes.”
“The characters express their beliefs through sincere conversations and actions, making it feel authentic and heartfelt.”
God's Not DeadSin is Like a Jail CellChristianity73.3Index scoreGod's Not Dead (2014), Pure Flix, et. al.
Weighted index scores, not percentages. Audience ranks refer to all 106 tested scenes.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Is easy to understand | 73% |
| Is emotionally moving | 70% |
| Places faith in contemporary/modern settings | 70% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Entertainment impact | 75% |
| Faith portrayal | 71% |
| Engagement impact | 68% |
“Because the comparison of the woman's life to a sinner fits well and makes you question God.”
“It shows faith as personal, not preachy.”
When stories connect, success follows
The study’s top scenes come from award-winning, widely watched titles.







Awards and audience figures are as published in the 2026 index; they are not live totals.
The findings
01 · Faith drives engagement
92%
Open to faith representation in entertainment.
Most viewers see a place for faith, whether central to the story, part of the background, or present through subtle references.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Central to the story | 23% |
| Present, but not the main focus | 51% |
| Subtle, light references | 18% |
| Not at all | 8% |
The three forms of inclusion total 92%. Report p. 14.
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
01 · Faith drives engagement
77%
Believe stories about a specific faith can have broad appeal.
A majority across ages, faiths, and political groups believe these stories can appeal broadly or somewhat broadly to all audiences.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| All entertainment consumers | 77% |
| Gen Z | 79% |
| Millennials | 83% |
| Gen X | 78% |
| Baby Boomers | 72% |
| Christian | 83% |
| Jewish | 78% |
| Muslim | 87% |
| Atheist / non-religious | 59% |
| Democrat | 75% |
| Republican | 82% |
| Independent / other | 73% |
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
01 · Faith drives engagement
Before and after exposure to scenes.
Viewers found content with faith themes more appealing and more relatable after watching the selected clips, including viewers who were not religious.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Before viewing scenes | 53% |
| After viewing scenes | 58% |
+5 percentage points+15 points among atheists / agnostics
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Before viewing scenes | 53% |
| After viewing scenes | 61% |
+8 percentage points+13 points among atheists / agnostics
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
02 · Honesty drives authenticity
6 of the top 10 scenes were emotional, reflective, and thought-provoking.
The three leading scenes share vulnerability and reflection. Audiences respond to emotional honesty and characters who grapple with belief.

Dr. Robby Thanks Whitaker
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Portrays struggle and doubt | 77% |
| Deeply emotionally moving | 72% |
| Invites reflection | 69% |

Sheldon Convincing Mom to Believe in God
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Portrays struggle and doubt | 73% |
| Deeply emotionally moving | 74% |
| Invites reflection | 70% |

I Love You
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Portrays struggle and doubt | 77% |
| Deeply emotionally moving | 74% |
| Invites reflection | 70% |
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
03 · Accessibility through familiarity
Family, love, and shared everyday experiences.
Familiar human moments help audiences connect to faith. Relationships make the experience recognizable.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Young Sheldon · Sheldon convinces his mom | 68% |
| Nobody Wants This · I Love You | 73% |
“Although we don’t know what has made mom question her faith, having Sheldon as her son and him telling her she is the best mom for him – it’s that warm feeling inside that the world needs right now.”
“The characters show sincerity and depth in their beliefs. That emotional honesty is what made it stand out as a good portrayal.”
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
03 · Accessibility through familiarity
92%
Open to seeing comedy or humor in the TV and movies they watch.
Comedy is the most sought-out theme. But the response to individual scenes depends on whether humor treats people and their faith respectfully.
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| Open to comedy / humor in TV and film | 92% |
| Say respectful humor is important in faith portrayals | 66% |
| Audience / measure | Percent |
|---|---|
| #6 · Nobody Wants This — Noah’s Sermon | 69% |
| #22 · Young Sheldon — Exploring Religion | 70% |
| #105 · Broad City — Yom Kippur | 48% |
| #106 · Mo — Nicolas’ Mom’s Prayer | 41% |
“When they threw in the random crypto joke… you can kind of chuckle a little bit… loosen people up and then… they’ll be more receptive.”
“It never got past the stereotypical assumptions that are typically associated with various religions.”
2026 Faith & Entertainment Index · HarrisX
Across faith traditions
The story and experience mattered more than a specific faith tradition. Explore each audience’s ten highest-ranked scenes.
Tools for storytelling
Tools and plot devices that help ground audiences.
What this means for creators
What the research makes clear
Real people. Real stakes. Audiences respond to faith when it shows up in everyday moments—doubt, love, grief, courage.
When belief is woven naturally into honest characters and lived experience, it doesn’t limit who’s watching. It widens the circle.
Done right, faith doesn’t just entertain. It invites reflection. Builds empathy. And connects people across belief lines.
Explore Faith & Media Connect
The complete picture
Download the full 71-page report, its complete rankings, and shareable social graphics.
Source: FAMI’s 2026 Faith & Entertainment Index and its downloadable HarrisX report.
The report supplies the exact interview count (12,723), scene count (106), and the correct “more relatable” label for the second before/after comparison. The web page repeats the “more appealing” label.
For Nobody Wants This · I Love You, Muslim rank #43 follows report p. 42; the source webpage says #87. The source embeds a Hacksaw Ridge clip for Noah’s Sermon; this page supplies the Netflix episode and timestamp instead.
Repeated, mismatched social commentary on the source page is not attributed to unrelated scenes here. Social listening is included where the report supports the scene association. The Pitt’s coding analysis follows report p. 39 rather than the unrelated awards list shown on the webpage.
In partnership with HarrisX.